Select Page

Oil and Water: Which paint, when and why

Updated Jun 12, 2022 | Posted Feb 12, 2020 | Product Advice, Professional insight | 7 comments

Oil and Water: Which paint, when and why?

By Ian Richardson

 

In the past I have always used oil-based paints for woodwork, being very disappointed with my first attempts using water-based satinwood. The early paints I tried were of very poor opacity and gave a disappointing finish. Oil gives you the ability to achieve an almost-miraculous smooth, opaque finish that you will (still) never get with water-based paints. I’ve recently used the Weathershield Dulux Gloss system to paint new external doors, surrounds and porch. I’m always pleased with the smooth, fine surface that I can get and, if my preparation is conscientious, the result seems to last many years before beginning to break down. Indoors, it’s a different story. Cleaning up is a nightmare, the fumes are unhealthy and unpleasant, and drying times make the job last for days.

Oil and Water: Which paint, when and why?

A pleasing result with oil-based paint on the Porch props.

 

Recently, I had to do extensive renovation and repainting in a large extension and decided to try a water-based version again. I prefer a Satinwood finish on interior woodwork and so I used the standard Quick Dry Dulux Undercoat and Satinwood Topcoat. This time, I found the QD undercoat excellent and felt that two coats was more than good enough to prepare the surfaces, which included new wood, pre-primed MDF and old, previously painted, doors. Two further topcoats of Satinwood gives a finish that is “whiter” than the oil and (I’m assured) does not yellow anywhere near as quickly. It also becomes (after a few days) incredibly durable to knocks and is very easy to clean.

 

The Newer Dulux Diamond satinwood may have been a better option. This paint can run if you’re not careful, but it is fully water-based and the finish is spectacular.

 

There are drawbacks: You have to work like lightning over the surface and make damned sure you have a good brushed-out finish in a relatively small area before moving on. There is no going back to “fix” runs and clumsy execution in the way you can readily do with oil-based paints. A foam roller works great on sills and smooth surfaces but you still can’t afford to hang about. If you leave a visible run or ridge for more than a few minutes, it becomes impossible to brush out. A careful inspection revealed a few “problematic” finishes that I would never have accepted from an oil-based paint. However skilled you are, I do not believe that it is possible to achieve the smooth surface finish, free of brush marks, which it is possible to get with oil. Even so, if you can adapt your technique in the ways that I suggest, I think that the results are very pleasing. When you look closely, the sills rolled with a fine foam roller give the orange-peel finish that I have heard described and fine brush marks are visible all over the finished woodwork. Even so, the finish is significantly “whiter” than an oil paint and I find the result very pleasing aesthetically, as long as you’re not expecting it to look like an oil-based paint.

Close-up of “Orange-Peel” surface finish on sill.

The corner of an outside door, from inside.  Gloss Weathershield on the external door and frame. Quick-Dry water-based skirting.  Both Brilliant White! (Please, no personal comments on the quality of the cutting-in.)

The corner of an outside door, from inside.

Gloss Weathershield on the external door and frame. Quick-Dry water-based skirting.

Both Brilliant White! (Please, no personal comments on the quality of the cutting-in.)

It is the ease and speed of cleaning up, that clinches it for me. I have always been uneasy about the volume of unpleasant solvents that I get over my hands, and whose fumes I am forced to inhale, as well as the quantities that inevitably end up going into the drain. A faint smell of ammonia was the only environmental issue that I could detect and cleaning up was easy. I was also able to complete at least two coats effortlessly in a single day of painting, whereas with oil I have to allow a day between each coat.

 

Another advantage of using water over oil if you can spray water-based paints with ease. The modern decorator will opt to spray wherever they can as the finish is superior and it is much quicker. This helps the decorator earn more money and keep their clients happy.

 

Despite the drawbacks, I would never go back to using oil-based paints again for internal paintwork. I will probably continue to use oil-based gloss for outside paintwork, but I may change my mind over that, too. Perhaps time for another systematic comparison?

Terraco Filler review – written by a decorator

Professional decorator Mike Cupit writes a full and hones Terraco Handymate filler review, a range of products designed for interior and exterior use.

Pioneer Spirit Renaissance Eco Review

Professional decorator Mike Gregory writes a full and honest Pioneer Spirit Renaissance Eco review. an entire range of environmentally friendly tools.

HB42 Caulk Review – Everything You Need

Professional decorator Mike Cupit writes a full and honest HB42 caulk review – by far the sexiest product of its type on the market.

Indasa E-Series Sander Review

Professional decorator Mike Cupit gives a full and honest review of the Indasa E-Series sander and extractor. A dust-free unit with loads of power!

Benjamin Moore Paint Review and Guide

Professional decorator Phil Dawe gives us his full Benjamin Moore paint review and guide. Some fantastic products, but a few negatives to look out for.

Fiddes Hard Wax Oil Review

Professional decorator Mike Cupit writes a full and honest Fiddes Hard Wax Oil review. A product used on interior timber.

GoodHome Masonry Paint Review

Professional decorator Mike Cupit writes a full and honest GoodHome masonry paint review. Would you use this product on your home?

Armstead Smooth Masonry Paint Review

Professional decorator Mike Cupit gives us his full and honest Armstead Smooth Masonry paint review. A quality trade product loved by decorators.

Sadolin Wet Wood Decking Stain Review

Professional decorator Mike Cupit gives a full and honest Sadolin Wet Wood Decking Stain review. Does this product really deliver what it claims to??

Maston Spraypaint 2K Aerosol Review

Professional decorator Mike Cupit gives a full and honest Maston Spraypaint 2K Aerosol review. Is this the best spray paint on the market?

Oil and Water: Which paint, when and why – Join the Decorators Forum UK on Facebook

7 Comments

  1. J.W.Painting

    Ive only ever used water based once and that was a hybrid jono’s aqua in a surgery but other than that always used oil because it’s cheaper and go’s further. it’s already hard enough being under cut by painter’s who use b and q gear

    Reply
    • Damien

      Agreed, and the water enamel seems to only last 3-6 months in rental properties.
      We use oil if we want it to last, water if we want to go back and repaint a year later.

      Reply
  2. Roger Bell

    I’m a convert to wb for eggshell and satin wood the gloss finish is a million miles away yet in my opinion , the main drawback for me is the opacity wb always seem to need an extra coat to cover maybe more suitable for a spray finish

    Reply
  3. Ben Thwaite

    There are ways to stop the quick drying of water based paints such as paint conditioners and by adding water. Also try using a better quality paint such as Isomat or Caparol. Dulux are the best known paint but are far from being the best quality.

    Reply
  4. BH Decorators

    Old school oil based however started using wb and to be fair am fairly happy with it the cheaper stuff is false economy though so stick with higher quality

    Reply
  5. RobV

    I moved to using wb inside and found sikkens satura the best though now akzo have binned it. I agree with previous comments re application . Poorer finish than old school oil but acceptable to most howevr the oil is trash now with 18-24 hr recoat . I think shelf life is dubious too as I recentley had dilux satinwod taking 3 daysto dry!!!.

    Reply
    • Dan

      Satura BL binned but was excellent. Akzo brought back a significantly improved Diamond Satinwood 2 years ago though compared to what it was like before

      Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Related articles

Paintbrush Filament Technology

Paintbrush Filament Technology

Peter Samuel from the Pioneer Brush company gives his expert insight into paintbrush filament technology and how it’s changed over the years.

What Paint do Professionals Use?

What Paint do Professionals Use?

Trade decorator Mike Cupit explains in depth what paint professionals like him use on their day-to-day jobs. This blog offers great insight.

Supplier directory

Bringing you the best products at competitive prices.

Decorators Forum uk

We are a UK based online community of professional decorators, combined across several online platforms. This site is the hub of everything we do, as well as keeping decorators up to date with all the latest news, events and reviews from within the industry.

Keep me updated

If you’d like us to keep you up to date please sign up for our email alerts.

You will have the option to unsubscribe at any point in the future should you no longer wish to receive communications from us. For more information, please review our privacy policy by clicking here

Follow us

The Decorators Forum UK is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases that you make. Please note that there is no additional cost to you if you purchase from Amazon via one of our affiliate links.